Coin Edition -

Legal expert Bill Morgan, known for his pro-XRP stance, has suggested that the recent ruling by District Judge Amy Berman Jackson in the Binance case strengthens the argument that XRP is not a security. Judge Jackson cited Judge Analisa Torres ruling in the Ripple case when dismissing parts of the SECs case against Binance.

In her Friday ruling, Judge Jackson dismissed the SECs claim that secondary market sales of Binances BNB token constitute securities. The ruling emphasized the need to distinguish between digital coins themselves and the offers to sell them.

Supporting this view, Judge Jackson referenced several district court cases involving SEC enforcement actions on cryptocurrencies, where courts differentiated between the alleged investment contracts and the tokens.

One of the references was Judge Torres statement in the Ripple case, which noted that the XRP token itself is not an investment contract. Judge Jackson found each of these differentiations consistent with the Supreme Courts interpretation of investment contract within the definition of a security.

In a commentary on the coverage of Judge Jacksons ruling, Morgan criticized CoinDesk for failing to acknowledge that Judge Torres was one of the judges whose observations Judge Jackson found clarifying and persuasive in differentiating a crypto asset itself from the alleged investment contracts.

To stress its significance, the legal expert argued that this decision reinforces the reasoning that XRP itself is not a security, as Judge Torres ruled on July 13, 2023.

In another tweet, Morgan emphasized the significance of Judge Jacksons ruling by noting its agreement with Judge Torres interpretation of the third prong of the Howey test, which concerns the expectation of profits based on others efforts.

He pointed out that this reasoning is preferred over Judge Rakoffs approach in the Terraform case, which did not distinguish between institutional and programmatic buyers of tokens.

The post Pro-XRP Lawyer Sees Binance Ruling as Boost for XRP Non-Security Status appeared first on Coin Edition.

This content was originally published on Coin Edition

Continued here:

Pro-XRP Lawyer Sees Binance Ruling as Boost for XRP Non-Security Status By Coin Edition - Investing.com Canada